1 year ago
It blows my mind that people use eternal punishment as a way to make their children behave. I read on facebook this morning the sentence “I love that no one can punish better than our Lord!” talking about threatening her children with the idea that “Jesus watches you all the time” and that he’ll punish you if you misbehave.
I don’t have children so I might be out of my element here.
But the way I look at it is based out of how I felt being told as a child that Jesus was “always with me”.
My grandma told me that “Jesus lived in my heart”. and I screamed, and cried and begged her to get him out, because I was terrified of having a little tiny man living in my body. Of course the idea of that is ridiculous, but how scared I felt was very real. I couldn’t have been more than 4 years old when that happened, because my grandma was still living in Nashville, she moved away from the city when I was 5 years old. My family loves to tell that story as a joke whenever I am around.
Now, that was the nice sweet version of “Jesus is always with you”, and I was terrified. I cannot imagine how scary it must be for children to be threatened with eternal punishment. Not to mention the extreme amount of guilt that comes along with being told you are ~always being watched~ there are so many rules against everything. What if you do something wrong on accident? Which, as humans we tend to make mistakes. If Jesus is the ultimate punisher, won’t he be very strict?
Won’t that guilt and fear carry over into adulthood? (yes) Why should you be a good person because god is always watching? Why not be a good person because it’s the proper thing to do?
I’m no expert on parenting… but isn’t that just wrong? To scare your child like that?
I like to think that the way Lyzz and Chris parent Annabelle is a good starting point for “If you misbehave you will be punished.” Instead of teaching Belle that she is going to upset Jesus, they teach Belle that Mom and Dad will be very upset. That she has hurt Mom and Dad’s feelings. Belle will be legitimately upset if you tell her that she has hurt your feelings. She will cry and cry and cry like you spanked her (which they don’t have to do because she is sensitive enough to be upset at the idea of upsetting you.) She’ll even say “I’m sorry.” sometimes hug you. The point is that she is genuinely sorry. Not because she’ll burn for eternity but because she has hurt someone that she knows. Now of course sometimes the 3yr old “I don’t care attitude” comes along and that’s where harsher punishments are needed like taking something away, not doing something for her etc etc.
I’m just trying to process the idea that god is the ultimate punisher. Which I mean isn’t a new idea.. but the idea of applying that to your parenting… Blows my mind.
For “all the good” that religion does (which can be disputed. Another post for another time.) it sure does have to be very scary to be effective.
- end2131 reblogged this from sanityscraps
- italianinsomniac likes this
- statickandy reblogged this from think4yourself
- foreverspectator likes this
- wildtabbykat reblogged this from lordhaternumber1superstar
- wildtabbykat likes this
- brittanynwilliams said: My husband no longer believes in God but he had extreme anxiety as a child because of punishment like this and hearing (when you’re a 5-6 year old boy) that you are going to hell if you’re bad.
- brittanynwilliams likes this
- adrialuka reblogged this from polishfeminist
- think4yourself reblogged this from kissing-whiskey
- think4yourself likes this
- bullymommy2012 said: That’s not how David & I are gonna be about it. We’re gonna do like my parents (including Catholic school) & he will have the option of believing as he pleases when he’s old enough to make that decision. We’ll just have a Catholic foundation for him.
- 0xfefe said: On top of that I was told that every dead person I had ever met was with me at all times to, and it really freaked me out because if I just wanted to be alone sometimes I didn’t know if they would go away or not.
- retrogradewaters likes this
- herbivorouslegitimous likes this
- morgansakitty likes this
- jadedahlia likes this
- blanksexual reblogged this from kyian
- gibsonwitch likes this
- mrssich said: My parents never used Jesus like this, however when they told me that he’s always watching over me, I got sad because that meant he would be watching when I was pooping and I felt sorry for him that he had to do that.
- lovingisknowingispower likes this
- housewifeonhoth likes this
- michaelhartog likes this
- dadnerdrants likes this
- toastedpopsicle reblogged this from sanityscraps and added:
- awmanohjeez reblogged this from theblacksunrising and added:
- doctordisaster likes this
- polishfeminist reblogged this from sanityscraps
- goodreasonnews likes this
- polishfeminist likes this
- lepetitselkie likes this
- dirtxtouchxskinxtongue likes this
- tempesterra likes this
- infamousnfamous likes this
- trxsxrms said: I Fucking love you.
- trxsxrms likes this
- invisiblelad likes this
- narwhalbutts reblogged this from sanityscraps
- poketrainersara likes this
- itsdetachable likes this
- kyian said: i completely agree with this
- kyian reblogged this from kissing-whiskey
- my-way-is-the-hyway11 likes this
- theblacksunrising reblogged this from sanityscraps
- sanityscraps reblogged this from invisiblelad
- sanityscraps likes this
- invisiblelad reblogged this from kissing-whiskey and added:
- cashela said: Irish Catholics are the best at this. No one guilts you like an Irish Catholic. The amount of fear and shame Ireland and its Priests have instilled on the nations psychology and relationship with religion is sad and a big part of why I’m an atheist
- adachimerica likes this
- kissing-whiskey posted this